Two Binary Thinking Patterns

By A.S.

Whenever there are two sides or options, people usually think in one of two ways:

Either “one is bad, one is good”. This is stereotypically (but not always) how right-wingers think.

Or “both are equally good.” This is stereotypically (but not always) how left-wingers think.

Both thinking patterns are overly simplistic. The reality can be that both sides are good, but not to the same extent; or both sides are bad, but not to the same extent; or that one is neutral; or that the situation is too nuanced to capture in “good” or “bad.”

When one side adopts “one is bad, one is good” and the other side adopts “both are equally good”, then discussions become intractable. Both sides clearly see that the other side is wrong, while not seeing that their own side is wrong too.

For example: the right goes “the native population is good, immigrants are bad.” The left counters with “any immigrant is the equivalent of a native-born person; illegal immigration isn’t a problem; building a wall to keep illegal immigrants out is bad.” Both are overly simplistic.

For example: the right goes “we’re the good country, that other country is bad and we should attack it or wage economic warfare against it.” The left goes “conflict is never the solution.” Both are overly simplistic.

For example: one person goes “my political party is good, and the other party is evil, and the country will be saved if my political party gets elected.” Another person goes “both sides are equally bad, it doesn’t matter which party is elected.” Both are overly simplistic.

For example: one side goes “Trump is good, the dark controllers / cabal are evil.” Another side goes “Trump and the dark controllers are both evil.” Both are overly simplistic. In reality, (the person pretending to be) Trump is gray and the dark controllers are evil.

For example, here’s a discussion I had with my twin flame:

Her: “You look good.”

Me: “Do you like this beard as much as you like the clean-shaven look?”

Her: “No, you look good in both cases, but I prefer the clean-shaven look.”

Me: “Then from your perspective, this beard is bad, because you prefer clean-shaven?”

Her: “No, the beard isn’t bad.”

Me: “But if you prefer clean-shaven, then by definition the beard must be bad from your perspective, right?”

Her: “No, I like the beard, but I like clean-shaven more.”

Me: [does not compute]

—–

With all my love,

A.S.

9 Replies to “Two Binary Thinking Patterns”

  1. Odd Fish

    Maybe thinking is a game whose rules are stacked against us to lead us astray. Thinking is based on concepts… cognitive entities assumed to be separate. A and B are separate and the two never meet.

    How can a multitude of separately construed entities accurately reflect a unified oneness field reality that lacks separateness? People think one is “right” and the other is “left”. What if they are both the continuum attaining deeper self-consciousness by looking at and reflecting on itself?

    Reply ↓
  2. John

    A solution can only be simplistic if the actual problem is really that complex or nuanced; and this is where debates usually heat up: politics has weaponized thinking and psychology to the point anything can be portrayed as important or negligible in both technical and moral aspects.

    Though this used to be done by mercenary think-tanks on the behalf of special interest groups, today you can feed AI with your purpose and let it conduct an entire beard discussion with your girlfriend! (In your texts, the arbitrary limit for questioning/complicating issues is usually marked by the word ‘obviously’ – in things which perhaps aren’t obvious for everyone)

    What makes the US and the West in general relatively more wild and free in that sense is that the burden of finding solutions has been openly relayed on the individual. Thinking individually is hard by itself, but since the weaponization most people begun being forced to simplify their thought in favor of intuition and emotion merely to survive, let alone prosper: Occam’s razor.

    Intelligence and the ‘air’ element is literally a double-edged sword. You need the soul fire to wield it, give it a purpose that, even if tempered by reason, is not born from it like in AI.

    Reply ↓
  3. A.S.

    To be clear, I know that some left-wingers and some right-wingers think in more nuanced ways and have more substantive arguments than what I outlined in the article. Some people already think in more nuanced ways than the two “lazy thinking patterns” I outlined here.

    Yet, many left-wingers and many right-wingers really do have the lazy thinking patterns I outlined here.

    Reply ↓
    1. ISmellBull

      Then explain to me why your wording is clearly sided in favor of the left.

      First, I’ve never seen the left say “both sides are good”. They actually say “everything I don’t agree with is fascism” (therefore a variation of “that bad this good” that you claim the right says – the left also doesn’t even know what “fascism” is at this point in time).

      Second, the right usually has some logical basis to their claims, even if some perceive it as “flawed” or “inhuman” in some points. Meanwhile the left has no basis other than their own baseless emotions.

      If anything this wording seems a lot like “leftism disguised as enlightened centrism” to me.

      Reply ↓
      1. the_complaint_department

        You have a point, though it kind of backfires into your presumed righteous intent.

        He indeed conceded that the left is prone to saying ‘both sides are good’, but you assumed this is a virtue while he might as well have said ‘both sides are bad’, because his point remains about being simplistic.

        His article record suggests he would indeed tend to overvalue a left perspective; but only as a honest attempt to correct a self-perceived right leaning tendency.

        So you basically ended up saying that this attempt to self-correct and give both sides an equal chance is a leftist trait – because the ‘true right’ wouldn’t.

        Reply ↓
        1. the_complaint_department

          Or maybe I’m just trying to earn my cut of all that ego loosh we are secretly harvesting in EoL. Your call.

          Reply ↓

Comment